December 13, 2010...11:41 pm

Eataly: New York’s New Mini Italy

Jump to Comments

Italy is Eataly

Day One, Eataly

I had already read some cynical comments about this Italian market. Having been to the markets in Italy, I agree that there’s really nothing like walking through one. It’s a cultural experience as well as a food high. And I’m sure a lot of people shared my first thought–yet another place to buy bread and cheese in New York? But a food-minded friend who just returned from Eataly loved it. “Don’t listen to that, just go,” she said. “You’ll see what I mean.”

And as I walked through the doors Sunday, I saw exactly what she meant. Eataly is a feast for the eyes, and if you love to cook—or your mind just revs with the possibilities at the sight of beautiful food in excess–you will truly believe that you’re in heaven. (Bring someone who also appreciates food, in case you find yourself fondling the jars of sundried tomatoes and talking to yourself, and don’t want to look like a crazy person.)

I entered to find baskets heaped with picturesque red grapes, and piles of tangerines. The lemons were so perfect I wanted to touch them all, just to see if they were real. Against one wall was an array of exotic mushrooms, and tiny, precious baby artichokes. All of this, before I even reached the shelves of cured meat and buffalo mozzarella.

And as I wandered on through this food playground, without even trying, I found myself standing in front of a case of delicate, fruit laden, ornate looking pastries. I froze, paralyzed by indecision, and the familiar, irrational fear that I might never see pastries again. This was purchase number one, and I agonized over it while the man behind the counter laughed at me. Understandably, since I could have chosen a name my first child in less time. Fortunately, the options included a miniature Napoleon, and a baby apple tart.

This expansive Italian market and eatery, opened in August of 2010 by Oscar Farinetti, Lidia and Joe Bastianich, and Mario Batali, James Beard award-winning chef of Babbo and El Posto in New York, is a food geek’s dream. If you never tire of perusing exotic sauces, collecting jarred vegetables you may or may not ever use, exclaiming over aged vinegars, if you hate tearing yourself away from the shelves at the newest cheese or gourmet shop in town (even though your pantry is overstuffed with fig jam and flatbread crackers) you will enjoy Eataly. One thing that the proprietors did right, and perhaps the most important thing, is the attention to layout and visual presentation.

Even the fruit at Eataly is beautiful.

The selection of pastas and olive oils alone entertained me for more than half an hour. All told, I spent several hours there marveling, shopping, and eating in the pasta shop. I took home cheeses, prosciutto, pastries, and bread, and all were difficult to choose, in part due to the overwhelming selection, and in part due to the excitement of seeing so many rare opportunities to indulge all in one place.

Finally, the cheese!

The seafood market was mesmerizing.

I shouldn’t have been surprised by  the quality of the choices, or by the  spectacular food displays.

Recently El Posto has received excellent reviews, and it appears that Batali has hit his stride as a chef, and as an entrepreneur. Meanwhile, Eataly’s creator, Farinetti, who ran a retail  electronics company UniEuro in Italy  until 2003, had already opened Eataly’s predecessor–a similar market in Turin, Italy–in 2007.

And chef and cookbook author Bastianich, best known for her  television series Lidia’s Italy, runs a dynasty of her own andhas already partnered with husband Joe Bastianich in other successful ventures with Batali–fifteen restaurants, in fact.

Copyright © 2010 Sara Daly


Leave a Reply